Usage and MechanicsModifiersL.6.1e

Double Negatives

Standard English uses one negative word per idea: “I don’t have any,” not “I don’t have none.”

Not started Jump to practice

Negative words say no: no, not (and -n’t), never, nobody, nothing, none, nowhere, neither. A few hide their meaning: hardly, scarcely and barely are negatives too. Like good and well, these words follow a rule of standard writing: one negative per idea.

Two fixes, one negative each.
Two negativesStandard written English
I didn’t see nobody.I didn’t see anybody. / I saw nobody.
We can’t hardly wait.We can hardly wait.
She won’t never quit.She will never quit. / She won’t ever quit.
They don’t have none.They don’t have any. / They have none.

Key idea

Standard written English uses one negative word per idea: “I don’t have any,” or “I have none.”

Why it works

Readers of formal writing expect one negative, and some read two as canceling out: “I didn’t see nobody” could seem to mean you saw somebody. One negative keeps the meaning certain.

This is a rule of standard writing, not of English everywhere. Older English stacked negatives for force: Chaucer wrote of his knight, “He nevere yet no vileynye ne sayde” (General Prologue, The Canterbury Tales), meaning he never said anything rude. Grammar books of the 1700s argued that two negatives cancel each other, and the one-negative rule became the standard for writing. Many dialects of English still use double negatives in speech, following their own regular pattern.

Worked example: Choose the standard form

There isn’t (nothing / anything) in the box.
  1. Isn’t is already negative.
  2. So the second word should be the positive anything.

Answer: There isn’t anything in the box.

Worked example: A hidden negative

I (can / can’t) hardly hear you.
  1. Hardly means “almost not.” It is a negative.
  2. Use the positive can.

Answer: I can hardly hear you.

Common mistake

Missing the hidden negatives hardly, scarcely and barely: “can’t hardly,” “couldn’t scarcely.” When one of these is in the sentence, leave out not.

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 1 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Leads to

Sources and further reading

@teddyrookbook GitHub