RhetoricThe Rhetorical SituationRI.9-10.6

Identifying Appeals

Most passages blend the appeals. Decide which one each sentence leans on most, and how they work together.

Not started Jump to practice

You have met ethos, pathos and logos one at a time. Real writing mixes them, often in the same paragraph, sometimes in the same sentence. Identifying appeals means deciding what each sentence leans on most, then seeing how they work together.

Three questions for every sentence.
AppealAskClues
EthosWhy should I trust this writer?experience, fairness, admitted limits, respect for the reader
PathosHow is this meant to make me feel?stories, vivid images, loaded words, shared values
LogosWhat reasons and evidence are offered?facts, numbers, examples, because and therefore
A sample letter asking for evening swim lessons (its details are made up for practice). Each sentence leans on one appeal; together they make the case.

Key idea

Label each sentence by the appeal it leans on most, then explain how the appeals support each other. Most strong passages use all three.

Why it works

Appeals rarely work alone. In the swim-lesson letter, the coach’s experience (ethos) makes the scared children (pathos) believable, and the facts about schedules (logos) show the fix is practical. Seeing the teamwork tells you why the passage persuades.

Worked example: One sentence, two appeals

“As a nurse who has treated dozens of bike injuries, I can tell you that a helmet turns many trips to the hospital into trips home.” Which appeal does it lean on most?
  1. “As a nurse who has treated dozens of bike injuries” builds trust: ethos.
  2. “A helmet turns many trips to the hospital into trips home” states a claim about results, warmly phrased.
  3. The sentence works mainly by asking us to trust her experience, so ethos leads, with some pathos in “trips home.”

Answer: Mostly ethos, supported by a touch of pathos.

Worked example: Lincoln’s blend

Gettysburg: “The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract.” What is the main appeal?
  1. It honors the soldiers and stirs reverence: pathos.
  2. “Our poor power” is also modest, which builds ethos.
  3. The main work is the feeling of reverence for the dead.

Answer: Mainly pathos, with modesty (ethos) in “our poor power.”

Common mistake

Looking for one label for a whole passage (“this speech uses pathos”). That misses how the appeals support each other, and it is rarely true. Label sentence by sentence, then say how they combine: “The writer’s experience makes the story believable, and the numbers show it isn’t a rare case.”
Your turn: label each sentence by its main appeal, then Check.

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 2 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Leads to

Sources and further reading

@teddyrookbook GitHub