Skip to content

AncientLight and Experiment

Ibn al-Haytham: Light, Sight and the Dark Room

A scholar of Basra and Cairo (c. AD 965–c. 1040) whose Book of Optics showed that we see because light enters the eye, and tested it.

Not started Jump to practice

Abu Ali al-Hasan ibn al-Haytham (c. AD 965–c. 1040), known in Latin Europe as Alhazen, was born in Basra, in today's Iraq, and did most of his known work in Cairo. He wrote on mathematics, astronomy and optics. His Book of Optics (in Arabic, Kitab al-Manazir), written in the early 1000s, changed how people understood light and sight.

Key idea

Ibn al-Haytham showed that we see because light travels from objects into our eyes, in straight lines, and he backed his claims with experiments anyone could repeat, such as light passing through a small hole into a dark room.

The problem

How do we see? Some ancient thinkers, such as Euclid and Ptolemy, said the eye sends out rays that touch things, like feeling with a stick. Others, following Aristotle, said objects send something to the eye. Each side had arguments. Ibn al-Haytham asked which idea fits what we can test.

How the idea came

He pointed out that looking at the Sun hurts the eye, and a bright light leaves an afterimage. Something is coming in. And when you open your eyes at night, you see distant stars at once: could rays from the eye really reach them that fast? He then built a full theory: every point of a lit object sends light out in all directions, in straight lines, and the eye collects it.

The dark room experiment

He described setting several lamps outside a room with a small hole in its wall. Each lamp made its own spot of light on the wall inside. Cover one lamp and its spot goes dark, and only that one. So light from each lamp travels in its own straight line through the hole, and the lines cross without mixing. Later scientists called a darkened room with a hole a camera obscura, Latin for "dark room."

Rays from the top of the tree pass through the hole and land low on the back wall; rays from the bottom land high. The picture is upside down. Drag the tree or change the hole size and depth.

Why it works

Light goes in straight lines. A ray from the top of the object must go down through the hole and keep going down, so it lands at the bottom of the screen. The bigger the hole, the more each point spreads into a blur; the smaller, the sharper but dimmer the image.

Worked example: How big is the image?

A tree 6 m tall stands 20 m from a pinhole. The back wall is 0.5 m behind the hole. How tall is the upside-down image?
  1. The two triangles, tree to hole and hole to wall, have the same shape.
  2. $\dfrac{h}{6} = \dfrac{0.5}{20}$, so $h = 6 \times 0.025 = 0.15$ m.

Answer: 0.15 m, or 15 cm, upside down.

Testing, not just arguing

What makes him stand out is his method. He tested claims with set-ups he described carefully, so others could repeat them, and he checked his ideas against measurements. He also wrote a book of Doubts Concerning Ptolemy, listing places where the great astronomer's work did not hold together. Many historians count him among the founders of experimental science; others point out that experiment had older roots too. Both agree his optics was a big step.

We don't quote Ibn al-Haytham here because the standard English translations of his books are recent and still under copyright. Everything above is in our own words.

Story or history?

A popular story says Ibn al-Haytham pretended to be mad to escape an impossible job: the Caliph al-Hakim had asked him to control the Nile's floods, and he saw it couldn't be done. The story comes from biographers writing after his death, and historians treat it with caution.

Timeline
WhenWhat happened
c. AD 965Born in Basra
early 1000sMoves to Cairo under the Fatimid caliphs
c. 1011–1021Writes the Book of Optics (the dates are approximate)
c. 1040Dies in Cairo
c. 1200The Book of Optics is translated into Latin as De aspectibus
1572Printed in Basel; read by Kepler and others

Worked example: A long road to print

The Book of Optics was finished around 1021 and printed in 1572. About how many years passed?
  1. $1572 - 1021 = 551$.

Answer: About 550 years.

What it led to

Latin scholars such as Roger Bacon and Witelo built on his optics. Kepler, around 1604, used his ideas to explain how the lens of the eye forms an upside-down picture on the retina. Leonardo da Vinci compared the eye to a dark room with a hole, and the camera obscura became a tool for artists and the ancestor of the photographic camera.

Common mistake

Thinking the hole makes the image upside down by some trick of the hole. Nothing flips: the rays simply keep going straight, so top and bottom cross at the hole.

Read more: Ibn al-Haytham, Book of Optics and Camera obscura.

Try it in the Science LabOptics Bench

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 2 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Nothing before it: a good place to start.

Leads to

This is one of the top rungs of Ancient and Medieval Inventors.

Sources and further reading