McGuffey's Third Eclectic Reader, Revised Edition · Lesson LVII · Part 6: Courage, waves and patience

57. Which Loved Best?

Goal: Your child reads a story-poem and decides which child really loved mother best, and why.

⏱ About 20 minutes · 7 steps

Open it at the Internet Archive ↗

You'll need

  • The book, open to this lesson
  • A notebook or lined paper and a pencil

What's in the book

A story-poem: John, Nell and Fan each say "I love you, mother," but only one of them shows it.

The lesson, step by step

  1. Warm up

    SayHow can you tell someone loves you, without them saying it?

  2. Words and meanings

    Before reading, find the three children's names in the poem: John, Nell and Fan.

  3. Read it aloud

    Your child reads. Read each child's "I love you, mother" in a different voice.

    Here is a line from it:

    "I love you, mother," said little John;

    Then let your child reread a favorite part, more smoothly.

  4. Talk about it

    SayWhat did John do after he said he loved mother?

    SayWhat did Nell do?

    SayWhat did Fan do all day? Which child loved mother best?

    Then talk about the lesson of the reading:

    Love shows in what we do, not only in what we say.

    Let your child look back at the page to find answers.

  5. Tell it back or write it

    Close the book.

    SayTell me what each of the three children did, and how mother guessed.

    An older child can write two or three sentences instead.

  6. Copywork

    Your child copies this from the book in their best handwriting:

    Busy and happy all day was she,

    Helpful and cheerful as child could be.

    Check capitals and marks together.

  7. Spelling

    Say each word, use it in a sentence, and have your child spell it aloud, then write it: mother, busy, happy, helpful, cheerful.

    Check together and fix any mistakes right away. Keep missed words for tomorrow's warm-up.

Afterwards

Reread the poem on the next day or two; try to say one stanza by heart.

Tip

Ask your child to do one helpful thing today without being asked, like Fan.

@teddyrookbook GitHub