Middle Egyptian IINegation

Negation with n

n before a verb form negates it, with a twist: n sḏm=f usually means "he did not hear", and n sḏm.n=f "he cannot hear".

Not started Jump to practice

You know the sḏm=f (What the sḏm=f Means) and the sḏm.n=f (What the sḏm.n=f Means). Put the negative n "not" in front of them and something surprising happens.

Key idea

n sḏm=f means "he did not hear", a past. n sḏm.n=f means "he cannot hear" or "he does not hear", a present or general statement. The two forms seem to swap their meanings when negated.

Why it works

The swap is less strange than it looks. The n negates a whole statement, and the forms after it are not quite the positive sḏm=f and sḏm.n=f you know. "He did not hear" denies that a hearing ever took place, so Egyptian used the form that names the act itself. "He cannot hear" denies that he has ever achieved hearing, a completed result, so it used the form of completion. Whatever the history, Gardiner's rule holds in practice: read n sḏm=f as a past, n sḏm.n=f as "cannot" or "does not".
The negated forms are learned as a pair.
PositiveMeaningNegativeMeaning
sḏm=fhe hears; may he hearn sḏm=fhe did not hear
sḏm.n=fhe heardn sḏm.n=fhe cannot hear, he does not hear
jr=fhe doesn jr=fhe did not do
gm.n=fhe foundn gm.n=fhe cannot find
sḏm.n=f "he heard". With the negative in front, n sḏm.n=f, it means "he cannot hear".

In hieroglyphs the negative n is written with a sign of two arms held out, palms down (Gardiner D35), a gesture of "nothing". It stands at the head of its clause, before the verb.

Worked example: A past negative

Translate n ḏd=j.
  1. n + sḏm=f: the past negative.
  2. ḏd=j "I say".

Answer: "I did not say."

Worked example: Cannot

Translate n gm.n=f.
  1. n + sḏm.n=f: the present negative, "cannot" or "does not".
  2. gm.n=f from gmj "find".

Answer: "He cannot find (it)."

Worked example: Write it

Write "they did not hear".
  1. A past negative uses n + sḏm=f, without the .n.
  2. sḏm=sn "they hear".

Answer: n sḏm=sn

Common mistake

Expecting n sḏm.n=f to be past because sḏm.n=f is past. This is the classic Middle Egyptian surprise, and nearly everyone falls into it at first. Check: when you see n before a verb, count the .n. With it, translate "cannot" or "does not"; without it, "did not".
Other negatives follow in the next lessons: nn for "there is no" and for the future (nn, "There Is No"), n sḏmt=f "he has not yet heard" (The sḏmt=f), the negative verb tm (The Negative Verb tm) and m "do not!" (Do Not!).

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 3 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Leads to

Sources and further reading

  • Alan H. Gardiner, Egyptian Grammar (Oxford, 1927), Lesson VIII: negation
  • Alan H. Gardiner, Egyptian Grammar (Oxford, 1927), Lesson XXVIII: n sḏm.n.f
  • James P. Allen, Middle Egyptian: An Introduction to the Language and Culture of Hieroglyphs (3rd ed., 2014), on negation of the sḏm=f and sḏm.n=f
@teddyrookbook GitHub