Skip to content

The Rhythm of Numbers · Physics · Newton · added

Newton’s Rosette

Newton asked what kind of pull would make a planet's orbit a closed ellipse, and found that the answer picks out one law. Here you can change the law. Make gravity weaken a little faster or a little slower than the square of the distance, and the orbit no longer closes: its closest point steps round the Sun and the path draws a flower.

How to use it

  • Choose a law from the buttons, or slide the power yourself. Power 2 is Newton’s law; power −1 is a spring.
  • Press Play. The gold dots mark each closest approach. If they pile up on one spot, the orbit closes.
  • Read the ladder under the picture. Each rung is a flower the orbit almost draws: so many petals in so many turns.
  • Stretch the orbit with the second slider. Under Newton’s law and under a spring, the orbit closes however stretched it is. Under any other law the step changes.

The orbit, seen from above

The gold dots mark each closest approach. With Newton's inverse-square law they all fall on one spot and the orbit is a closed ellipse. With any other law the closest point steps round the center, and the orbit draws a rosette.

The ladder behind the rosette

fractionfigurehow nearly it closesnext term

Between one closest approach and the next, the body goes round the center by a fixed amount. Written as a fraction of a turn, that amount has a continued fraction, and its rungs are the figures the rosette almost draws: a fraction p/q is a flower of q petals drawn in p turns. A large next term means the flower nearly closes before it starts to turn.

What is known and what is ours. The rule for nearly round orbits is Newton's (Principia, Book I, Proposition 45): if the pull weakens as distance to the power p, the closest and farthest points are 180°/√(3 − p) apart. That only two laws close every orbit, the inverse square and the spring, is Bertrand's theorem (1873). Reading the step as a continued fraction, and the rosette's flowers as its rungs, is this project's addition. The orbits here are computed step by step in your browser.

Read more

Newton, in plain words →The Tide Machine →Huygens’s Gears →The paper, Chapter 19 →

Notes and sources

  • This instrument goes with Sections 19.1 and 19.2 of the paper.
  • The preset “Mercury’s shift, a million times bigger” uses power 2.16. In 1894 Asaph Hall suggested that a power of 2.00000016 would explain the slow turning of Mercury’s orbit that Newton’s law leaves over. The idea failed when it was tried on the Moon, and Einstein’s general relativity explained the turning in 1915.
  • The orbits are computed step by step in your browser, so very long runs slowly lose accuracy. Nothing you do here is sent anywhere.

← Back to The Rhythm of Numbers