Money and taxes · Easy · about 30 minutes

Insurance Basics

Insurance is a deal: you pay a regular price, and the insurance company agrees to pay for certain big losses. Knowing the key words, especially premium, deductible, copay, and limit, helps you compare policies by what they really cost in a year.

When to teach it: Watch from about 12, help from about 15, do it alone from about 18.

🔬 The math behind it

You'll need

  • Your state insurance department's website
  • Written quotes from several insurers
  • A calculator
  • A list of what you want covered

Step by step

Tick each step as you go if you like; ticks stay on this device.

Math

How it works: Comparing deductibles by total yearly cost

Insurance spreads risk. Many people pay premiums, and that money pays for the few who have big losses in a given year. That's why a premium reflects the losses the insurer expects.

Choosing a deductible is a trade-off: a higher deductible lowers your premium, but you pay more when you have a claim. You can compare plans by figuring the total you'd pay in a year.

Worked example with made-up numbers for car collision coverage: Plan A has a $500 deductible and a $1,200 yearly premium. Plan B has a $1,000 deductible and a $950 yearly premium. With no claims, A costs $1,200 and B costs $950. With one $3,000 claim, A costs $1,200 + $500 = $1,700 and B costs $950 + $1,000 = $1,950. With two such claims, A costs $2,200 and B costs $2,950.

Plan B saves $250 a year in premium but costs $500 more for each claim. So B comes out ahead in a year with no claims, and A comes out ahead in any year with at least one claim. Which is better depends on how likely a claim is and whether you could pay the higher deductible.

yearly cost = premium + (deductible × number of claims), when each claim is larger than the deductible

Try it: Roll a die once for each pretend year; a 1 means you had one claim. Track the total cost of Plan A and Plan B over 10 years. Which plan cost less in your game? Play again with a claim on a 1 or a 2 and see if the answer changes.

Keep learning: Ray's Arithmetic

Teaching it to your kids

  • Look at your own health insurance card together and find the copays.
  • Let a teen sit in when you shop for car insurance and fill in a comparison table of the quotes.
  • Use the dice game to show that a higher deductible is a bet you might win or lose.

Tips

  • If you have a car loan or lease, the lender may require collision coverage.
  • Ask each insurer how accidents and credit history could affect your rate.
  • Your driving record, the car you drive, where you live, and how much you drive can all affect the price of car insurance.
  • Short-term health plans often have lower premiums but cover less of your costs.

Common mistakes

MistakeInstead
Picking the lowest premium without looking at the deductibleCompare the total yearly cost, including what you'd pay if you had a claim.
Choosing a deductible you couldn't actually payPick a deductible you could cover from savings after a loss.
Buying only the state minimum without thinking it overMinimum limits may be too low for a serious crash. Price out higher limits too.
Comparing quotes with different coveragesUse the same coverages, limits, and information for every quote.

Where to get help

  • Your state insurance department can tell you your state's insurance requirements and whether an agent or company is licensed.

Sources

Free how-to guides for families, with nothing to earn, pass or send in. They follow U.S. rules and sources; your owner's manual, product labels and state and local rules come first. This guide explains how things work; it isn't personal financial, tax or legal advice.

@teddyrookbook GitHub