Art History IIThe Baroque

Caravaggio and Tenebrism

Caravaggio painted ordinary-looking people lit by a sharp beam in deep darkness (tenebrism), as in The Calling of Saint Matthew (1599–1600).

Not started Jump to practice

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571 to 1610) came to Rome from Lombardy in the early 1590s and changed European painting within a few years. In What Makes Art Baroque you met his Calling of Saint Matthew. Here we look at how he made light do the storytelling.

Painters had long modeled forms with light and shadow, a method called chiaroscuro (Italian for "light-dark"). Caravaggio pushed it to an extreme: most of the picture sinks into deep shadow, and a single hard light picks out faces, hands and a few objects. This extreme form is called tenebrism, from the Italian tenebroso, "dark, murky." He also painted saints and apostles as ordinary-looking people, with lined faces, dirty feet and torn sleeves, which some patrons found shocking and many viewers found moving.

Key idea

Tenebrism is chiaroscuro at its extreme: deep darkness with a sharp, focused light. Caravaggio used it, with ordinary-looking models, to make religious stories feel immediate.

Why it works

A spotlight works like a stage. When almost everything is dark, the eye goes straight to what the light touches, so the painter controls exactly where you look and in what order. Caravaggio painted from posed models, lit from one side, and the strong light makes the figures look solid enough to touch.

Looking closely: The Supper at Emmaus

Caravaggio, The Supper at Emmaus, 1601. National Gallery, London.

Describe. At an inn table, the risen Christ blesses bread. Two disciples react: one grips the arms of his chair, the other flings his arms wide. The innkeeper stands, puzzled. Analyze. Light from the upper left falls on the faces and the white cloth; the background is a dark brown wall. The outflung arms push forward and back in depth, and the fruit basket teeters at the very edge of the table, as if it could fall into our space. Interpret. This is the moment of recognition in the story, when the disciples realize who their companion is; the reaching gestures and the basket pull us into that moment.

The arms and the table edge make strong diagonals; the lit face of Christ is the focal point.

Common mistake

People mix up chiaroscuro and tenebrism. Chiaroscuro is any modeling with light and dark, and Leonardo used it softly. Tenebrism is its extreme: most of the picture in deep shadow, with a hard, narrow light. Check: if large parts of the picture are nearly black and the light is a sharp spotlight, it is tenebrism.

Worked example: Chiaroscuro or tenebrism?

A portrait shows a face gently turning from light into soft shadow against a mid-gray background. Is that tenebrism?
  1. There is modeling from light to shadow, so it uses chiaroscuro.
  2. The shadows are soft and the background is mid-gray, not deep darkness.
  3. There is no sharp spotlight against near-black.

Answer: No. It is chiaroscuro, but not tenebrism.

Caravaggio's style spread fast. His followers, the Caravaggisti, carried tenebrism to Naples, Spain, France and Utrecht in the Dutch Republic. You will meet one of the greatest of them, Artemisia Gentileschi, in the next lesson, and his influence again in Velázquez and Rembrandt.

Caravaggio's life was stormy: he was often in trouble with the law and fled Rome in 1606. Historians still piece together his last years from scattered records. His paintings, not his legend, are what changed art.

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 2 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Leads to

Sources and further reading

@teddyrookbook GitHub