Art History IThe Renaissance

Mannerism and the Late Renaissance

After about 1520, Mannerist artists stretched proportions, crowded space and used cool, strange colors; Bronzino's portraits and El Greco's View of Toledo show the range.

Not started Jump to practice

After about 1520, many artists in Italy turned away from the calm balance of the High Renaissance. They stretched proportions, crowded or flattened space, twisted poses, and used cool, shimmering or unusual colors. Art historians later named the style Mannerism, from the Italian maniera, "style" or "manner": for the art writer Giorgio Vasari, writing in 1550, maniera was a term of praise for refined, graceful artifice.

Agnolo Bronzino, Eleonora of Toledo with Her Son Giovanni, about 1545, oil on panel. Uffizi Galleries, Florence.

Looking closely: Eleonora of Toledo. Bronzino, court painter to the Medici dukes of Florence, painted Duchess Eleonora, wife of Cosimo I, with one of her sons. She sits stiff and upright against a flat blue background, her face smooth and pale as porcelain, her expression cool and distant. Her gown, gold and black brocade with a pattern of pomegranates, is painted thread by thread and seems more alive than she is. The portrait is about rank and dynasty, not personality: a perfect, polished, unapproachable image.

Sofonisba Anguissola, The Chess Game, 1555, oil on canvas. National Museum, Poznań, Poland.

Looking closely: The Chess Game. Sofonisba Anguissola of Cremona painted three of her younger sisters at a game of chess, watched by their governess. The sister at the left looks out at us, about to win; the youngest grins; the sister at the right lifts her hand in surprise. It is a portrait of a family moment, warm and lively, in rich costume. Anguissola became so admired that she later served at the court of Philip II of Spain.

El Greco, View of Toledo, about 1599 to 1600, oil on canvas. The Metropolitan Museum of Art.

Looking closely: View of Toledo. El Greco ("the Greek," Domenikos Theotokopoulos, 1541 to 1614) was born on Crete, trained as an icon painter, studied in Venice and Rome, and settled in Toledo in Spain. Here the city climbs its hill under a stormy sky of torn clouds and flashes of light. The greens are unnatural and vivid, and he moved the cathedral tower to a place it does not really stand. It is less a map than a vision of the city. El Greco is often grouped with Mannerism, but his style is so personal that many scholars treat him as a case of his own.

Key idea

After about 1520, Mannerist artists stretched proportions, crowded space and used cool, strange colors; Bronzino's portraits and El Greco's View of Toledo show the range.

Why it works

Why turn away from balance? Many reasons are offered: artists who had studied Raphael and Michelangelo wanted to go beyond them; courts prized elegance and display; and times were troubled, with Rome sacked by imperial troops in 1527 and Christendom divided by the Reformation. Scholars weigh these differently.

Worked example: High Renaissance or Mannerist?

One portrait is relaxed and warm, the sitter turned toward us in a stable pyramid. Another shows a sitter stiff and remote, with porcelain skin, against a flat blue ground, her gown more vivid than her face. Which is Mannerist?
  1. The first describes Raphael's Castiglione: High Renaissance balance and warmth.
  2. The second describes Bronzino's Eleonora: cool, polished, artificial.

Answer: The second.

Common mistake

Thinking Mannerist distortion was a lack of skill. These artists could draw "correctly" and chose elegance and strangeness on purpose. Check: does the same artist draw hands, cloth and faces with complete control? Then the distortion is a choice.
Mannerism follows the High Renaissance.

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 2 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Leads to

Sources and further reading

@teddyrookbook GitHub