CivicsFoundations of GovernmentD2.Civ.8.9-12

Forms of Government

Governments differ by who rules: one person (monarchy, dictatorship), a few (oligarchy) or the people (democracy, direct or representative); a republic is governed by elected representatives, and authoritarian and totalitarian states allow no real opposition.

Not started Jump to practice

Once we know what government is for, the next question is who holds power. Since Aristotle, writers have sorted governments by whether one person, a few people or the many rule.

Who rulesFormWhat it means
OneMonarchyA king or queen, usually by inheritance. An absolute monarch has unlimited power; a constitutional monarch reigns under laws made by an elected parliament.
OneDictatorshipOne leader holds power by force or by setting aside the rules, with no real way for the people to remove him.
A fewOligarchyA small group, often defined by wealth, family, party or military rank, holds power.
The manyDirect democracyCitizens vote on laws themselves, as in ancient Athens' assembly or a New England town meeting.
The manyRepresentative democracyCitizens elect people to make laws for them.
The manyRepublicPower rests with the people and is used by elected representatives; there is no hereditary monarch.

Two more terms describe how much a government allows. An authoritarian state concentrates power and allows no real opposition or free elections. A totalitarian state goes further: a ruling party tries to control nearly every part of public and private life, as in Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union under Stalin.

Why it works

The founders feared tyranny by one ruler, and they also feared a majority that runs over everyone else. In Federalist No. 10 Madison wrote that a pure democracy, "a small number of citizens, who assemble and administer the government in person," has no cure for faction, while "A republic, by which I mean a government in which the scheme of representation takes place, opens a different prospect." So they chose representatives, elected under a written constitution that limits them.

Key idea

The United States is both a representative democracy and a republic: the people rule through elected representatives, under a constitution. Direct democracy also appears inside it, in town meetings and state ballot measures.

Worked example: Classifying a government

In a country, a queen inherits the throne, but an elected parliament makes the laws and chooses the prime minister. What form is it?
  1. Who makes the laws? An elected parliament, so the people rule through representatives: a representative democracy.
  2. Is there a hereditary head of state? Yes, the queen, so it is a monarchy, but a constitutional one.
  3. A republic has no hereditary monarch, so this is not a republic.

Answer: A constitutional monarchy that is also a representative democracy (not a republic).

Worked example: Direct democracy inside a republic

Voters in a state approve a new law by ballot initiative. Which form of democracy is that?
  1. The voters themselves decide the law; no representative votes for them.
  2. That is direct democracy, used here within a representative system.

Answer: Direct democracy (within a representative democracy).

Common mistake

Thinking "democracy" and "republic" are opposites. A republic is one kind of democracy: rule by the people through representatives, with no monarch. Check: ask "who makes the laws?" (the people or their representatives) and "is the head of state hereditary?" These are two separate questions.
Sort by who holds power.

Practice

Pass with 3 right answers, the last 2 in a row. Each right answer earns 2 XP.

Loading practice…

Builds on

Leads to

Sources and further reading

@teddyrookbook GitHub